City Cast Madison logo

‘It’s a Wonderful Life’ And 9 More Madison Holiday Shows

Posted on November 26, 2024   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Rob Thomas

Rob Thomas

A family of four pose in front of a green moon.

Capital City Theatre’s new musical version of “It’s A Wonderful Life” runs through Sunday. [Capital City Theatre]

Capital City Theatre was looking for its own holiday show like “The Nutcracker” or “A Christmas Carol.” Something that everybody knows and associates with the holidays, and that they could stage every year and become an annual tradition in Madison.

What better than the classic 1946 movie that people watch year after year?

“It’s A Wonderful Life,” a new musical based on Frank Capra’s tearjerker starring Jimmy Stewart as a good man who learns how much his life has affected others, is now playing in the Mitby Theater and Madison College’s Truax Campus and runs through Sunday, Dec. 1.

Working off the film’s original screenplay (which is in the public domain), Andrew Abrams wrote the music and John Atkins wrote the lyrics and books. The musical has been a project literally 20 years in the making for the duo.

Abrams talked about the creation of the musical with Madison Minutes.

What is it about “It’s A Wonderful Life” that has become such an important part of the holidays for people 80 years later?

We want those stories, like “A Christmas Carol,” where a character goes through turmoil, like Scrooge or George Bailey, and comes out on the other side with kindness. We all want that, and crave that. Especially right now of all times.

How did you approach writing the music for the show?

People always ask me if I’ve contemporized the music at all. If you walked in and didn’t know, you’d think it was written in the early 1960s. It has a slightly forward-looking feel, but you know what decade you’re in as you watch the show. It roots you in the time of the movie, and I didn’t want to take the audience out of that.

Have you updated the original 1946 film for modern audiences?

We have a more diverse cast than in the film, trying to represent today’s world more than 1946 Hollywood. Another thing is the view of suicide. Suicide is such a major part of this movie, and it wasn’t until recently that people were talking openly about it.

Our director, Michael Cotey, gets up before rehearsals and gives these great speeches that make everybody cry. He talks about how if one or two people are affected by the musical to reconsider dark thoughts they’ve had, or seek help, we’ve done our job.

Here’s a few more holiday shows to bring cheer in Madison this season:

Dance Fabulous sends up “Die Hard,” “Wicked,” “Mean Girls” and more holiday chestnuts in this saucy and sassy revue at the Bur Oak on Tuesday, Friday, and Saturday.

Kanopy Dance goes global with this multicultural celebration that ranges from Scandinavian folklore to Indian community dances. At Overture’s Promenade Hall Dec. 5-8.

This based-on-a-true-story of a battlefield armistice during World War I has become an annual tradition for Four Seasons Theatre. Dec. 5-15 in Overture Center’s Playhouse.

Maestro John DeMain puts on the Santa hat for this annual celebration, including Madison Youth Choirs and the Mt. Zion Gospel Choirs. It runs Dec. 6-8 in Overture Hall.

It just wouldn’t be the holidays without Children’s Theatre of Madison’s annual production of the Charles Dickens classic, running Dec. 7-22 in the Capitol Theater at Overture Center.

Madison Ballet brings back this enchanting production, with the Wisconsin Chamber Orchestra providing live accompaniment of Tchaikovsky’s beautiful music. See it in Overture Hall Dec. 13-22.

Zany plays called “pantos” are a holiday tradition in England, and Bartell Theatre does its own version every December. Ruh roh! The show takes on classic cartoons Dec. 13-28.

The Pogues’ holiday classic inspires this Irish celebration of the season, featuring musicians, dancers, and an audience sing-along, at the Barrymore Theatre on Dec. 15.

Dance Wisconsin has been doing its own version of “Nutcracker” for nearly 50 years, with vocals from the Monona Grove High School singers. See it at Shannon Hall on Dec. 21 and 22.

Share article

Hey Madison

Sign up for your free daily toolkit to get the most of the city you love.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

Madison's Best

See All
Madison's BestMay 12

Wisconsin Authors Are an Open Book on New Podcast

On the new podcast "Writing Forward," Madison writer Jeff Oloizia interviews Wisconsin authors about their writing process, how to be suc...

A man in a blue shirt stands next to a shelf of books.
Madison's BestApril 30

Your Guide to May 2026 in Madison

From Brat Fest to Tulip Fest, from 'Newsies' to Charlie Berens, there's lots going on in Madison this spring.

A man in a gray shirt in front of a blue brick wall.
Madison's BestApril 29

The Madison Mystery Tour Is Coming To Take You Away

Over a half-century after they broke up, the Beatles still have a huge hold on popular culture. For over a decade, the Madison Mystery To...

A man in a bow tie plays an electric guitar behind a man playing a keyboard.
Madison's BestApril 27

Madison’s Circus Scene isn’t Clowning Around

While Circus World in Baraboo is what put Wisconsin's circus scene on the map, there's lots of acrobatics, clowning and more going on in...

A man and a woman in a circus ring juggling hoops.
Madison's BestApril 21

Your Guide to the Barrymore Theatre’s Fit Film Fests

In addition to being a favorite spot for live music and comedy, the Barrymore Theatre on Madison's east side hosts one-night-only film fe...

The interior of a theater full of people.
Madison's BestApril 13

How to Celebrate Earth Day 2026 in Madison

Earth Day is personal for Wisconsin, because it was U.S. Sen. Gaylord Nelson who made it a national day to celebrate and promote environm...

A man in a plaid shirt peruses a rack of clothes.
Madison's BestApril 6

After ‘John Wick,’ Madison-Born Writer Wants Something ‘Normal’

Derek Kolstad may be best known for writing the first three "John Wick" movies. His latest action film, "Normal" starring Bob Odenkirk an...

A sheriff holding a gun is flanked by two other people.
Madison's BestApril 1

Your Guide to April 2026 in Madison

Along with the nicer weather comes the return of the Dane County Farmers’ Market to the Capitol Square on April 11.

A woman arranging purple and white flowers.