City Cast Madison logo

Madison Night Mares Fight for League Championship

Posted on August 6, 2025   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Jade Iseri-Ramos

Jade Iseri-Ramos

A group of softball players celebrating at home plate.

Players celebrate one of Hilary Blomberg’s 11 home runs this season. Can you spot Madison Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway in the stands cheering them on? (Photo courtesy of Madison Night Mares)

In just their second season in existence, Madison’s summer collegiate softball team is in a bid for the championship title. This week, the Madison Night Mares are in the middle of a best-of-three series for the Northwoods League against the Minot Honey Bees. The two teams faced off 10 times in the regular season, with the Night Mares winning nine of those games.

Here’s a recap of how the Night Mares got here – and what to watch for in the playoffs.

Night Mares Dominate the Regular Season

The Madison team came out as the top seeded team in the league with an impressive 35 wins and 7 losses, including a 16-game winning streak in July. The Night Mares also claimed player of the year (Hilary Blomberg), pitcher of the year (Karlie McKenzie), and coach of the year (Lexi Godwin) in the league awards. Six Night Mares, including McKenzie and Blomberg, were also selected for the NWL Softball Postseason All-Star team.

First-year head coach Godwin told the Cap Times, “pitching has kind of been the separator for us." The team’s top pitcher McKenzie held a 10-0 record in regular season, while pitchers Paytn Monticelli and Kendall Weik both maintained impressive 7-1 records.

Godwin also credits the team’s dominance to strong hitters, including Blomberg, who leads the league with 11 home runs and 47 RBIs. The fans have been rooting for their home team with an average attendance of about a thousand.

Night Mares Won Game One on Monday Night

The Night Mares and the Honey Bees squared off in North Dakota on Monday night. Dozens of fans showed their spirit by gathering at the Harmony Bar to watch the game together online. The Madison team took home the win with a 10-2 final score.

How to See Tonight’s Championship Game

The Night Mares will be back home in Madison to face the Honey Bees again Wednesday at 6:05 p.m. at Warner Park. Tickets can be purchased online or at the box office. The game can also be streamed online courtesy of the Northwoods League.

If the Night Mares lose tonight and the series goes 1-1, the deciding Game 3 will be played tomorrow – same time, same place.

For more, City Cast Madison host Bianca Martin spoke with team general manager Samantha Rubin last year before the Night Mares inaugural season.

Share article

Hey Madison

Sign up for your free daily toolkit to get the most of the city you love.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

Madison, Explained

See All
Madison, ExplainedSeptember 15

The House on the Rock Is Even Weirder Than You Think

Located about an hour west of Madison, The House on the Rock is one of Wisconsin's most infamous, and certainly oddest, tourist attractio...

People in a narrow room covered in glass.
Madison, ExplainedAugust 31

How Voit Farm Will Transform Madison’s East Side

For 160 years, the 65-acre Voit Farm was a Madison fixture. Explore the ambitious new redevelopment plan bringing hundreds of homes, gree...

Two large blue buildings under construction.
Madison, ExplainedAugust 24

Test Your Madison News Knowledge!

This week's news quiz dives into everything from a new downtown restaurant to a big shake-up at UW-Madison. Can you get every question ri...

Francesca Hong and David Crowley stand on stages.
Madison, ExplainedAugust 20

Uncovering the Ghosts of Madison’s Wonder Bar

Discover the history of Madison's Wonder Bar Steakhouse as neighbors fight to save the Prohibition-era mobster hangout from a developer's...

A two-story brick building with boarded up windows and ivy growing up the side was the location of Wonder Bar Steakhouse. It now sits abandoned.
Madison, ExplainedAugust 18

Fitchburg Took Down Flock Cameras, But Will Test Others

Fitchburg ends its Flock Safety license plate reader contract over privacy concerns, testing alternatives from Axon and Motorola despite...

A city street on a winter's day with a Flock camera attached to a pole.
Madison, ExplainedAugust 10

Meet the Madison Democrats Running For Assembly District 76

Find information about the candidates running for Wisconsin's Assembly District 76 seat in the upcoming primary election.

Five political candidates sit on a stage with microphones in front of them.
Madison, ExplainedAugust 10

Your Guide to the August Primary Election in Wisconsin

Get ready for the Wisconsin election on August 11. Learn where to vote in Madison, what ID to bring, how to vote early, and mail-in ballo...

A white sign with a United States flag image and the words “VOTE HERE VOTE AQUI” stands upright in front of a Madison municipal building.
Madison, ExplainedAugust 3

How State Government Is Reducing Its Footprint in Madison

Wisconsin is shrinking its downtown Madison office space. Learn how the long-term Vision 2030 plan will change the state government's phy...

A gray multi-story building in downtown Madison.

The latest in Madison

Madison NewsSeptember 14

How the Historic Meta Settlement Will Impact Wisconsin

Get the details on Wisconsin’s $200M share of the historic $17B Meta settlement as Attorney General Josh Kaul joins City Cast Madison to...

Wisconsin Attorney General Josh Kaul stands at a podium
Food & DrinkSeptember 10

How the Essen Haus Has Avoided the Wrecking Ball...So Far

Celebrate Oktoberfest 2026 at Madison's iconic Essen Haus on Saturday, Sept. 12! Enjoy a full day of live indoor/outdoor music, German be...

The front of The Essen Haus - a grey building with gold trim. The restaurant sign is pink.
Madison NewsSeptember 9

How the U.S.-Canada Trade War Could Hurt Wisconsin Farmers

Canada has retaliated with $20 billion in tariffs against the U.S. following a breakdown in trade talks. Here is how these new trade barr...

a brown cow looks out through a holding pen.
Madison's BestSeptember 8

Ann Garvin Has a Surprise in Store For Her Readers

Madison author Ann Garvin shares her glee in throwing readers a curveball with her poignant, messy new novel, hitting stores September 8.

Author Ann Garvin poses in front of a red wall.
Food & DrinkSeptember 3

Where To Eat Halal in Madison

Madison’s first-ever Halal Restaurant Week runs Sept. 4-13. Discover local restaurants offering special menu options prepared in accordan...

A plate of meat and vegetables.
Madison's BestSeptember 1

What To Do in Madison in September 2026

Discover the best things to do in Madison, Wisconsin, in September 2026! From vibrant fall festivals to concerts and athletic events, pla...

A post for the theater show "Steady as She Goes" by Erica Berman. An illustration of a woman with blue flowing hair that looks like ocean waves.
Food & DrinkAugust 27

The Best New Restaurants in Madison

This month’s list of the area’s best new restaurants includes a new outpost for a wildly popular local pizza chain, a new sushi spot near...

A blue bowl filled with a scallop tiradito.
Madison NewsAugust 19

UW Floats Tuition Freeze in Exchange For State Aid

The Universities of Wisconsin propose a 2027–29 tuition freeze and inflation-capped increases, conditional on a $190 million state fundin...

A UW Madison campus building - red brick with white columns.