City Cast Madison logo
September 9, 2025

Police Monitor Faces Criticism For Lack of Transparency

City Cast Madison

Police Monitor Faces Criticism For Lack of Transparency

00:00:00
View all City Cast Madison episodes

Madison’s Office of the Independent Monitor is meant to be a check on the Madison Police Department, receiving complaints and feedback, making data-based recommendations, and upholding transparency and accountability. But what happens when the office’s own transparency practices are brought into question? 

Back in May, reporters requested records for communications between the monitor’s office and the Madison Police Department. There was no response.. After Isthmus reporter Liam Beran wrote a story about the records on Aug. 28, the office finally released the records. Today, Beran talks to host Bianca Martin about the months-long saga and what comes next for the office.

Mentioned on the show:

An Exit Interview with Madison’s Outgoing Police Chief [ 🎧City Cast Madison]

Madison’s Independent Police Monitor Does What Exactly? [ 🎧City Cast Madison]

Why Madison’s Police Oversight Agencies Are the Most Empowered in the Country [ 🎧City Cast Madison]

2025 Office of the Independent Monitor Annual Report

👋 Wanna talk to us about an episode? Leave us a voicemail at 608-318-3367 or email madison@citycast.fm. We’re also on Instagram

📧 You can get more Madison news delivered right to your inbox by subscribing to the Madison Minutes morning newsletter. 

🏠 Get more from City Cast Madison when you become a City Cast Madison Neighbor. You’ll enjoy perks like ad-free listening, invitations to members only events, and more. Join the City Cast Madison Neighbors program!

Looking to advertise on City Cast Madison? Check out our options for podcast and newsletter ads. Learn more about the sponsors of this September 9th episode:

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Hey Madison

Sign up for your free daily toolkit to get the most of the city you love.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

Latest Episodes

See all
April 24

City Threatens Police Monitor’s Independence, Beagles Stay at Ridglan, and Delays at Public Market

Tuesday, Madison’s City Council heard hours of public comment and debate before ultimately punting a proposal to tighten regulations for...

City Cast Madison podcast episode art
April 23

Your Guide to Madison Coffee Shops

Here in Madison, we’re blessed with dozens of great coffee shops. Whether you’re looking for a quick jolt of caffeine or a spot to hang o...

City Cast Madison podcast episode art
April 22

How Happy is Madison, Really?

Last month, WalletHub released a study that ranked Madison the 12th happiest city in the US. Is Madison actually that happy? We asked YOU...

City Cast Madison podcast episode art
April 21

Miss Wisconsin and BGC’s Michael Johnson on Leading the Next Gen

What does it take to lead young people through anxious, high-stakes times? City Cast Madison host Bianca Martin talks with Miss Wisconsin...

City Cast Madison podcast episode art
April 20

Charlie Berens on Wisconsin Grandpas, Data Centers, and Running for Office

Oh hey der. Did you know that comedian and Wisconsin legend Charlie Berens will be performing on May 7 and 8 at the Overture? He is known...

City Cast Madison podcast episode art
April 19

'Your City Could Be Better': Why Seattle Gives Every Voter $100 — Presented By City Cast Madison

Could public financing get more Madisonians involved in local elections? For the last decade, the City of Seattle has issued $100 in vouc...

City Cast Madison podcast episode art
April 17

Extreme Weather, UW Athletics Shakeup, and Olbrich's Expansion Contested

Madison was just hammered by extreme weather — flooding, high winds, hail the size of baseballs, and possibly (maybe) even a tornado?! Ho...

City Cast Madison podcast episode art
April 16

The Neighborhood Bars That Hold Madison Together

Madison has no shortage of cocktail bars and dives to satisfy your need to imbibe. But there’s something extra special about those neighb...

City Cast Madison podcast episode art
April 15

How Isthmus Keeps It Real, 50 Years In

Longevity in the media industry is hard to come by. Longevity for a local alternative weekly is an even tougher task. But Isthmus has man...

City Cast Madison podcast episode art
April 14

How Safe Are Our Streets?

How safe are Madison’s streets? After several high profile crashes this year, including one that resulted in the death of a 17-year-old h...

City Cast Madison podcast episode art