City Cast Madison logo

The Best Out-of-the-Ordinary Pizzas in Madison

Posted on January 15
Rob Thomas

Rob Thomas

A pizza on a brown wooden table.

Zafferano Ristorante estimates that it sells 200 butter chicken pizzas every day. (Zafferano Ristorante)

Italian-Indian cuisine? It sounds like an unusual combo, but Zafferano Ristorante in Fitchburg has found a hunger in the local dining scene for their inventive fusion of two cuisines. So much so that the owners are planning a second restaurant on the Capitol Square, Eloura, that will serve Mediterranean food with East Asian influences.

On the City Cast Madison podcast today, host Bianca Martin talks to co-owner Kalyani Venkatraman about their current and future adventures in dining.

City Cast

Does This Go Together? And Other Questions Asked by Madison’s Fusion Trend Setters

00:00:00

One of the most popular dishes at Zafferano that mixes Indian and Italian influences in the butter chicken pizza. But Madison is no stranger to unusual and inventive kinds of pizza. Here’s some of our favorite places to get an out-of-the-ordinary pie.

It may seem normal to us, but outsiders actually consider mac ‘n’ cheese pizza to be kind of weird! As Verona residents will soon find out, Ian’s continues to push the envelope of pizza creations. January’s special slices include a crab rangoon pizza, a kielbasa mac pizza and a pho pizza!

Johnson Street’s thick Detroit-style pizza is so distinctive that even a plain cheese hits different than other pizza. But Molten Monkey has a range of innovative specialty pies, including the Tik Tik Boom with ginger brined red onions and a tikka masala base, an Umami Bomby with four different kinds of mushrooms, and Not on the First Date with an avocado cream base and a chimichurri drizzle.

Sal’s Jersey-style pizza is a favorite from downtown Madison to Sun Prairie, and their solid lineup of flavors include the new Ossobuco Royale with bone marrow, lemon mint gremolata and toasted breadcrumbs, and the Joey Bananas with banana peppers, hot honey and fresh jalapenos

Glass Nickel has been a neighborhood institution in Madison for decades, with wittily-named specialty pies like the Portabella Lugosi, the Vegan Pad Thai Pie and my favorite, the Fetalicious. They also rotate in new limited-edition pies each month, such as the Big Mac-inspired (but legally distinct) Special Sauce.

This popular spot in Verona and Sun Prairie packs them in with an extensive pizza menu, including the new Autumn Sage Pizza with prosciutto, fresh sage and brown butter roasted butternut squash, as well as the Green Goddess Pizza with pesto cream sauce, the Asian Chicken pizza with General Tso’s sauce, and my favorite, the clearly Canadian Maple My Bacon Pizza.

This King Street favorite is known for serving “steel pan pizza,” a deep-dish Wisconsin spin on Detroit pizza, as well as wood-fired pizza. For something different, try the King Gyro pizza with roasted lamb and tzatziki sauce or the She’s A-Maize-ing with sweet corn, bacon and habanero basil cream.

This elegant Willy Street spot offers artisan pizzas like the Sweet Corn with squash, fresh ginger, coconut and lime and the Brassacre with brussel sprouts and bacon.

Did I miss your favorite one-of-a-kind Madison pizza? Email me and let me know! 🍕

Share article

Hey Madison

Sign up for your free daily toolkit to get the most of the city you love.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

Food & Drink

See All
Food & DrinkMay 14

These Madison Butcher Shops Are a Cut Above

With summer coming up, you might want to stock up for the next cookout. Here are some of Madison's favorite butcher shops, from Meat Peop...

A man in glasses peers at a stack of hamburger patties.
Food & DrinkMay 7

Supper Clubs in Madison You Have To Try

You can savor the Wisconsin supper club tradition without traveling far from Madison, hitting historic spots like Tornado Steak House, Ka...

A photo of a plate of food and a nighttime photo of the exterior of a restaurant.
Food & DrinkApril 23

Madison's Best New Restaurants

This month's list of new restaurants include a new coffee shop on Winnebago Street, an ice cream shop coming to downtown Sun Prairie and...

The interior of a coffee shop with a blond wood counter.
Food & DrinkApril 16

Madison’s Favorite Neighborhood Bars

Madison has its share of high-end cocktail bars, but there's nothing like a neighborhood bar where it feels like everybody knows your nam...

The exterior of a bar with brick and red wood.
Food & DrinkApril 9

Where To Find the Best Bagels in Madison

Madison has plenty of great bagel options, from Mermaid Kitchen to Gotham Bagels to Bagels Forever.

Metal racks of bagels on a counter.
Food & DrinkApril 2

Where to Go For Easter Brunch in Madison

Don't have plans for the family on Easter morning? Don't worry. Most spots in Madison have openings still for their brunch events, includ...

A place setting with pink plates and pink bunny statues.
Food & DrinkMarch 19

The Best Bakeries in Madison

Looking for a sweet treat? From cookies and croissants, to bread and beyond, we've got you covered.

A glass display case full of cakes and loaves of bread.
Food & DrinkMarch 12

Sweet Corn, Strawberries and Maple Syrup: Why Dane County Loves Its Specific Food Fests

Whether it's Middleton and its mustard, Sun Prairie and its sweet corn, or Fitchburg and its strawberries, there are some Dane County com...

Two children at a table sampling maple syrup.

The latest in Madison

Madison, ExplainedMay 18

How Smart Studios Put Madison on the Musical Map

Why did Nirvana, Smashing Pumpkins, Death Cab for Cutie and other bands want to record songs in Madison? As a new documentary explains, S...

A two-story red brick building on a street.
Madison's BestMay 12

Wisconsin Authors Are an Open Book on New Podcast

On the new podcast "Writing Forward," Madison writer Jeff Oloizia interviews Wisconsin authors about their writing process, how to be suc...

A man in a blue shirt stands next to a shelf of books.
Madison, ExplainedMay 4

Quiz: Are you a True Madisonian?

You may live in Madison, but are you a true Madisonian?

A downtown street scene with a capitol dome at the top of the street.
Madison's BestApril 30

Your Guide to May 2026 in Madison

From Brat Fest to Tulip Fest, from 'Newsies' to Charlie Berens, there's lots going on in Madison this spring.

A man in a gray shirt in front of a blue brick wall.
Madison's BestApril 29

The Madison Mystery Tour Is Coming To Take You Away

Over a half-century after they broke up, the Beatles still have a huge hold on popular culture. For over a decade, the Madison Mystery To...

A man in a bow tie plays an electric guitar behind a man playing a keyboard.
Madison's BestApril 27

Madison’s Circus Scene isn’t Clowning Around

While Circus World in Baraboo is what put Wisconsin's circus scene on the map, there's lots of acrobatics, clowning and more going on in...

A man and a woman in a circus ring juggling hoops.
Madison's BestApril 21

Your Guide to the Barrymore Theatre’s Fit Film Fests

In addition to being a favorite spot for live music and comedy, the Barrymore Theatre on Madison's east side hosts one-night-only film fe...

The interior of a theater full of people.
Madison HistoryApril 15

The History of Madison in 10 Isthmus Headlines

Madison alt-weekly Isthmus is celebrating its 50th anniversary this month. The editors dug through the archives to look to see how the ne...

A black-and-white photo of two men surrounded by newspapers.