City Cast Madison logo

The Best Out-of-the-Ordinary Pizzas in Madison

Posted on January 15
Rob Thomas

Rob Thomas

A pizza on a brown wooden table.

Zafferano Ristorante estimates that it sells 200 butter chicken pizzas every day. (Zafferano Ristorante)

Italian-Indian cuisine? It sounds like an unusual combo, but Zafferano Ristorante in Fitchburg has found a hunger in the local dining scene for their inventive fusion of two cuisines. So much so that the owners are planning a second restaurant on the Capitol Square, Eloura, that will serve Mediterranean food with East Asian influences.

On the City Cast Madison podcast today, host Bianca Martin talks to co-owner Kalyani Venkatraman about their current and future adventures in dining.

City Cast

Does This Go Together? And Other Questions Asked by Madison’s Fusion Trend Setters

00:00:00

One of the most popular dishes at Zafferano that mixes Indian and Italian influences in the butter chicken pizza. But Madison is no stranger to unusual and inventive kinds of pizza. Here’s some of our favorite places to get an out-of-the-ordinary pie.

It may seem normal to us, but outsiders actually consider mac ‘n’ cheese pizza to be kind of weird! As Verona residents will soon find out, Ian’s continues to push the envelope of pizza creations. January’s special slices include a crab rangoon pizza, a kielbasa mac pizza and a pho pizza!

Johnson Street’s thick Detroit-style pizza is so distinctive that even a plain cheese hits different than other pizza. But Molten Monkey has a range of innovative specialty pies, including the Tik Tik Boom with ginger brined red onions and a tikka masala base, an Umami Bomby with four different kinds of mushrooms, and Not on the First Date with an avocado cream base and a chimichurri drizzle.

Sal’s Jersey-style pizza is a favorite from downtown Madison to Sun Prairie, and their solid lineup of flavors include the new Ossobuco Royale with bone marrow, lemon mint gremolata and toasted breadcrumbs, and the Joey Bananas with banana peppers, hot honey and fresh jalapenos

Glass Nickel has been a neighborhood institution in Madison for decades, with wittily-named specialty pies like the Portabella Lugosi, the Vegan Pad Thai Pie and my favorite, the Fetalicious. They also rotate in new limited-edition pies each month, such as the Big Mac-inspired (but legally distinct) Special Sauce.

This popular spot in Verona and Sun Prairie packs them in with an extensive pizza menu, including the new Autumn Sage Pizza with prosciutto, fresh sage and brown butter roasted butternut squash, as well as the Green Goddess Pizza with pesto cream sauce, the Asian Chicken pizza with General Tso’s sauce, and my favorite, the clearly Canadian Maple My Bacon Pizza.

This King Street favorite is known for serving “steel pan pizza,” a deep-dish Wisconsin spin on Detroit pizza, as well as wood-fired pizza. For something different, try the King Gyro pizza with roasted lamb and tzatziki sauce or the She’s A-Maize-ing with sweet corn, bacon and habanero basil cream.

This elegant Willy Street spot offers artisan pizzas like the Sweet Corn with squash, fresh ginger, coconut and lime and the Brassacre with brussel sprouts and bacon.

Did I miss your favorite one-of-a-kind Madison pizza? Email me and let me know! 🍕

Share article

Hey Madison

Sign up for your free daily toolkit to get the most of the city you love.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

Food & Drink

See All
Food & DrinkSeptember 10

How the Essen Haus Has Avoided the Wrecking Ball...So Far

Celebrate Oktoberfest 2026 at Madison's iconic Essen Haus on Saturday, Sept. 12! Enjoy a full day of live indoor/outdoor music, German be...

The front of The Essen Haus - a grey building with gold trim. The restaurant sign is pink.
Food & DrinkSeptember 3

Where To Eat Halal in Madison

Madison’s first-ever Halal Restaurant Week runs Sept. 4-13. Discover local restaurants offering special menu options prepared in accordan...

A plate of meat and vegetables.
Food & DrinkAugust 27

The Best New Restaurants in Madison

This month’s list of the area’s best new restaurants includes a new outpost for a wildly popular local pizza chain, a new sushi spot near...

A blue bowl filled with a scallop tiradito.
Food & DrinkAugust 13

These Madison Restaurants Are Gone But Not Forgotten

We also asked our readers and listeners to share their favorite defunct Madison restaurants, and dozens of you responded. Here are some o...

A strip mall restaurant with a green-and-white sign.
Food & DrinkJune 18

The Best Ice Cream in Madison

There are plenty of spots to indulge in a cold scoop (or several) of ice cream in Madison. Here are some of the best local spots in town.

A white building with a glass door with red trim.
Food & DrinkJune 11

Where to Watch the World Cup in Madison

The 2026 FIFA World Cup tournament kicks off today, and Madison soccer fans are ready. Here's where to watch the matches, including bars...

A man in purple cheers surrounded by fans in bleachers.
Food & DrinkMay 14

These Madison Butcher Shops Are a Cut Above

With summer coming up, you might want to stock up for the next cookout. Here are some of Madison's favorite butcher shops, from Meat Peop...

A man in glasses peers at a stack of hamburger patties.
Food & DrinkMay 7

Supper Clubs in Madison You Have To Try

You can savor the Wisconsin supper club tradition without traveling far from Madison, hitting historic spots like Tornado Steak House, Ka...

A photo of a plate of food and a nighttime photo of the exterior of a restaurant.

The latest in Madison

Madison, ExplainedSeptember 15

The House on the Rock Is Even Weirder Than You Think

Located about an hour west of Madison, The House on the Rock is one of Wisconsin's most infamous, and certainly oddest, tourist attractio...

People in a narrow room covered in glass.
Madison, ExplainedSeptember 15

How To Guard Against Ticks in Wisconsin This Fall

Tick season isn't over yet. Learn what to expect from fall tick activity in Dane County and get expert tips on how to protect yourself an...

A close-up photo of a small eight-legged insect on a human arm.
Madison NewsSeptember 14

How the Historic Meta Settlement Will Impact Wisconsin

Get the details on Wisconsin’s $200M share of the historic $17B Meta settlement as Attorney General Josh Kaul joins City Cast Madison to...

Wisconsin Attorney General Josh Kaul stands at a podium
Madison NewsSeptember 9

How the U.S.-Canada Trade War Could Hurt Wisconsin Farmers

Canada has retaliated with $20 billion in tariffs against the U.S. following a breakdown in trade talks. Here is how these new trade barr...

a brown cow looks out through a holding pen.
Madison's BestSeptember 8

Ann Garvin Has a Surprise in Store For Her Readers

Madison author Ann Garvin shares her glee in throwing readers a curveball with her poignant, messy new novel, hitting stores September 8.

Author Ann Garvin poses in front of a red wall.
Madison's BestSeptember 1

What To Do in Madison in September 2026

Discover the best things to do in Madison, Wisconsin, in September 2026! From vibrant fall festivals to concerts and athletic events, pla...

A post for the theater show "Steady as She Goes" by Erica Berman. An illustration of a woman with blue flowing hair that looks like ocean waves.
Madison, ExplainedAugust 31

How Voit Farm Will Transform Madison’s East Side

For 160 years, the 65-acre Voit Farm was a Madison fixture. Explore the ambitious new redevelopment plan bringing hundreds of homes, gree...

Two large blue buildings under construction.
Madison, ExplainedAugust 24

Test Your Madison News Knowledge!

This week's news quiz dives into everything from a new downtown restaurant to a big shake-up at UW-Madison. Can you get every question ri...

Francesca Hong and David Crowley stand on stages.